Mahommed v State of Queensland [2006] QADT 21 (24 May 2006)
- Type of outcome
Anti-Discrimination Tribunal decision
- Year
2006
- Contravention
Discrimination
- Attribute/s
Religious belief or activity
- Area
Administration of State laws and programs;
Supplying goods or services- Outcome
Complaint upheld; Compensation of $2,000 was awarded
Note: under the Corrective Services Act 2006, there are now restrictions on the tribunal ordering compensation. Any compensation arising out of imprisonment will be taken to pay compensation to the victims of crime or any child support or outstanding fines and penalties.
Summary
A Muslim prisoner was given the same general food as other prisoners, even though he had informed the prison on his arrival that he only ate meat that was halal. After ten months at the prison, he made a written request for halal meat, but his request was declined. He continued efforts to obtain halal meat, and eventually he was provided with tinned halal meat. The tinned meat was unsatisfactory so he stopped eating it, and he kept trying to obtain fresh halal meat. After two and a half years, he was transferred to a lower security prison. He was again given the general food of other prisoners. After three months he met with the food supervisor who initially refused his request for fresh halal meat. Instead, it was agreed he would be given food supplements such as eggs, cheese, nuts etc. Eventually the prisoner was given fresh halal meat that he cooked in the prisoner unit for the rest of his time in prison.
The tribunal said that when the prison provided the man with the same food as the general prison population, it imposed a term on him that he eat the general diet provided to prisoners. He could not comply with that term because of his religion.
The prison was able to cater for prisoner diets for numerous other medical and cultural reasons, and was able to meet the cost of supplying fresh halal meat. The fact that the man was serving a long sentence was relevant because providing supplements is a temporary measure. In the circumstances, the term was not reasonable.
When the prison provided the prisoner with a vegetarian diet with supplements and tinned halal meat, it was less favourable treatment of him because of his religion. Although prisoners would find their meals unpalatable from time to time, the man received substantially more unpalatable meals because he was put on a vegetarian diet when he was not a vegetarian. He also did not always receive the supplements he was supposed to receive. The tribunal found he regularly and frequently experienced difficulty with the supply and content of his meals.
The tribunal decided there had been both direct and indirect discrimination of the man, and awarded him compensation of $2,000.
The tribunal recognised that the principle of provision of halal meat to prisoners was significant. By the time of the hearing of this complaint, all Muslim prisoners in Queensland gaols who requested halal meat were being provided with fresh halal meat.